Caralamelia

Then use roar and feel poggers with it, you still got your big damage stick there, complain roar doesnt buff you as much as you want to do the big deps and people who wanted a dual ability can still use eclipse now that is reliable which one you end up using

A fair argument but why on umbra of all frames? disabling this passive could be done by just using regular excalibur and dont say its because of the higher stats because its mostly negligible if their passive made an actual difference on a situation the only honest reason to go umbra over excalibur is it being free and the howl during archon hunts

Honestly fine with this, eclipse only being used for the damage just feels bad on itself, we already got damage in the form of roar so why have two? why not have a strong one and one that is weaker but comes with the alternative damage reduction?

I understand you can technically stack them, but considering we are already tight in modspace why would anyone pick warrior's rest over power drift?, and anyone who isnt maxing out power strength why wouldnt they just pick power drift and a stronger ability strength mod?