No coop for 2 Xbox same ISP

[(XBOX)Thunderman CPK]

Hello,

I have manies issues with Warframe on 2 Xbox on the same ISP (only 1 public IP address).
In Warframe, I can't invite a friend to join me.
At the best, only 1 Xbox can see the other player, launch a invit but an error message tell "The player is offline).

All the network test on Xbox is OK : (Internet, Multiplayer and NAT Open)
I try with other game (Rocket League and Warhammer Vermintide) without problem.

I use PFsense 2.4.3-RELEASE (amd64)

### Firewall / NAT / Outbound
Mode : Manual Outbound NAT

Interface : WAN
Source : Xbox1 (alias for 192.168.0.16)
Port Source : any
Destination : any
Port Destination : anay
NAT Address : WAN
NAT Port : any
Static Port : YES

Interface : WAN
Source : Xbox2 (alias for 192.168.0.17)
Port Source : any
Destination : any
Port Destination : anay
NAT Address : WAN
NAT Port : any
Static Port : YES

### Services / UPnP & NAT-PMP

- Enable UPnP & NAT-PMP
- Allow UPnP Port Mapping
- Allow NAT-PMP Port Mapping

- External Interface : WAN
- Interface : LAN + loopback
- ACL Entries : allow 1-65535 192.168.0.16 1-65535
- ACL Entries : allow 1-65535 192.168.0.17 1-65535

### System / Advanced / Firewall & NAT

- NAT Reflection mode for port forwards : Pure NAT
- Enable NAT Reflection for 1:1 NAT
- Enable automatic outbound NAT for Reflection

### Firewall / NAT / Port Forward

Nothing, because I activate UPnP

Actually, I must use the bad ISP-box only for Warframe ;-)

Regards,

Aym

[(XBOX)DJFARG0]

a few years back and was able to fix it with one Xbox (DMZ"D) outside routing table, static IP and the other in the route table with specific port forwarding and also static IP. Im sure I have notes somewhere ill do some digging and check back. Based on your notes it seems like you are comfortable with the port tables and plowing through your router, there is a rather large security risk with DMZ connections as they are naked by default and exposed to all sorts of unwanted traffic but hey its a console and im sure you are not banking or accessing your 401k from there.

[(XBOX)Thunderman CPK]

Hi,

Thanks for your reply. I don't want to use DMZ for Xbox. Warframe seems to have a particular network-level behavior.

[(XBOX)O Cheeky 1]

My son and I have separate consoles and unable to play warframe together- various time outs or instant failures.

Even worse, invites sent to me appear in his game and vise versa. 

If I try to invite him, i get the invite saying (my gamer tag) has invited you to a game. which, upon accepting says the invite is for a different account and to log in (or something meaning the same)

We have no issues playing ark survival or ROBLOX etc together.

Each console has it's own unique LAN IP but share WAN IP.

[(XBOX)Thunderman CPK]

Hello,

I did a full reinstall pfsense, with the maximum permission fot the 2 Xbox One.

### Firewall / NAT / Outbound
Select Mode : Manual Outbound NAT

Interface : WAN
Source : any
Port Source : any
Destination : any
Port Destination : any
NAT Address : WAN
NAT Port : any
Check Static Port

### Services / UPnP & NAT-PMP

- Check : Enable UPnP & NAT-PMP
- Check : Allow UPnP Port Mapping
- Check : Allow NAT-PMP Port Mapping

- External Interface : WAN
- Interface : LAN + loopback

### Firewall / Rules / LAN

Protocol : IPv4+6
All the rest : ANY

### Firewall / Rules / WAN

2 rules for each XboxOne (first rule Xbox IP is destination and second this is the source)
XboxOne1 192.168.0.16 - XboxOne2 192.168.0.17

Protocol : IPv4
Source : any
Port : any
Destination : 192.168.0.16 (XboxOne1)
Port : any
Gateway : any

Protocol : IPv4
Source : 192.168.0.16 (XboxOne1)
Port : any
Destination : any
Port : any
Gateway : any

### System / Advanced / Firewall & NAT

- NAT Reflection mode for port forwards : Pure NAT
- Check : automatic outbound NAT for Reflection

### Firewall / NAT / Port Forward

Nothing, because I activate UPnP

It's works for Xbox Live test (in configuration -> network) and games (rocket league) instead of Warframe !!

I get the same error when I invite (the player is offline...) in Warframe menu

Regards.