Jump to content

JohnMarkLee

PC Member
  • Posts

    240
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by JohnMarkLee

  1. One big problem i see here with comparing these two ships.

     

    The space ships in Star Wars are very well detailed, with lineart, numbers and interior views. Not only that but most of the common technologies in Star Wars are relative explained, hence we know limits and potential of it.

    From these source materials we know how big a Star Destroyer or Republic warship is. We know how many fighters they carry, how much crew and infantry they have on board and how many weapons they have.

     

    The space ships in Warframe are basicly all over the place with no official lineart, no official numbers and a totaly UNKNOWN interior, because the game randomizes the levels even on space ships.

     

    If you run through a Galleon you might occasionaly have 3 massive cannon rooms after another or you don't see any at all. Sometimes you can also have a u-turn in a Corpus ship with the windows to the outside not actualy showing the other part of the U.

     

    That means we have NOTHING to base any speculations about the potential of the Galleons on.

     

    The same goes for the infantry units.

     

    In Warframe enemies are dumber than a sack of hammers and it depends on their level how much damage they can actualy take. They also display no sense of tactics or even ranking. Enemies just rush at you in all kind of combinations. No NCOs leading squads, no COs giving orders over loudspeakers and no sense of squad setups.

    Which means we can actualy NOT use the game as a basis to judge how good or bad the Grineer are actualy in combat.

     

    We only have the trailers for that and in those they are all killed by a single shot, including from weapons like the humble Braton. They also once again just rush the Tenno like idiots with no sense of being organized in any way.

     

    So can a blaster rifle kill a Grineer in one shot? Or would they take a dozen plasma bolts before even a humble Lancer would go down? Do Grineer actualy make tactical decessions or do they just run into blaster fire all the time? We DON'T know.

     

    Meanwhile there is a ton of source material for Clone and Storm Trooper which can balance out their not so splendind portrail in the movies and cartoons.

    Actualy Clone Wars even gives the Clone Troopers some credit occasionaly.

     

    Though that brings me to a general problem with vs. threads like these. These are entirely different fictional universes with different technological limitations we are comparing here.

    The limits and potential of the technologies between these two universes are too different.

     

    For example. In Star Wars almost every ship can cruise around half the galaxy in days or weeks. In Warframe space ships can't even leave the old Sol System.

     

    Meanwhile Grineer use kinetic weapons which seem to have compressed space (pocket dimensions) for their magazines, have access to teleportation technology and make liberal use of cybernetics.

    Which puts technology in Star Wars to shame.

     

    In the end, i simply think these Vs. threads only make sense with settings where technology and vehicles are relative well explained.

    But Warframe is simply not fixed enough yet to use it for this.

    Meh, enough lore to explain the Grineer for me 

  2. Do Galleons even have many guns on them? There's one tile where there's a big cannon, but that's just one tile. Meanwhile the Republic Star Destroyers are named that for a reason.

    Well there are cannons in those Galleon tiles like you said. They would always be shooting at nothing though lel. 

    Dude.... The Galleon is like an ant compared to the Star Destroyer!

     

     

    except if all of the Grineer are [9999], then they'll win

    The size difference didnt look too much apart to me, but what do I know I got asian eyes. ~_~

    1 Darth Vader = Grineer lose.

    True but wrong Era :P

     

     

  3. GRINEER

    - 1 Galleon

    yQv3Bzw.png

    Fighters:

    - 50 Dargyn

    - 20 Shield Dargyn

    - 20 Hellion Dargyn

    - 10 Shield-Hellion Dargyn

    FPAjqRl.pngEx0qbQC.png

    LMmju7f.pngCKVLzma.png

    - 50 Ogma

    z1fwVaw.png

    - 25 Dreg 

    - 25 Lancer Dreg

    f0uzMAY.png4RK1qUk.png

    Crew:

    (Personnel on Galleon)

    - 30 Commanders

    - 100 Lancers

    - 100 Troopers

    - 50 Hellieon

    - 50 Heavy Gunners

    - 30 Drahk Master

    - 25 Seekers

    - 25 Eviscerators

    - 20 Scorch 

    - 10 Bombard

    - 5 Manic

    - 5 Napalm 

    Boarding:

    (Boarding parties do not take units away from garrison crew members)

    - 30 Boarding Pods (Containing 1 Heavy Gunner, 2 Lancers, 2 Hellieon and 2 Troopers each)

    - 20 Boarding Pods (Containing 1 Commander, 1 Seeker, 1 Scorch, 1 Drahk Masters, 1 Eviscerator each)

    - 5 Boarding Pods (Containing 1 Manic, 1 Bombard, 1 Napalm each)

     

    REPUBLIC

    - 1 Star Destroyer

    sT5IkI8.png

     

    Fighters:

    - 50 ARC-170 Starfighters

    scabHOp.jpg

     

    - 25 V-Wing Heavy Starfighters

    3asxlVT.jpg

     

    - 25 BTL Y-Wing Bombers

    KbYKWQK.jpg

     

    - 50 V-9 Torrent Fighters

     

    VHyLKTG.jpg

    Crew:

    (Personnel on Cruiser)

    - 1 Commander

    - 4 Captains

    3PvP0hA.jpg

     

    - 200 Clone Marines 

    OpFDoxr.jpg

     

    - 50 Heavy Gunners (Equipped with Miniguns)

    - 75 Jet Troopers (Equipped with Jetpacks)

    - 50 Clone Snipers 

    - 25 Heavy Troopers (Equipped with Rockets)

    - 50 Flame Troopers (Equipped with Flamethrowers)

    - 20 Clone Commandos

    c3Dcrhl.jpg

     

    - 20 Shadow Troopers (Jamming devices and Cloaks)

    GYluILB.jpg

     

    - 20 ARC Troopers 

    79U743C.jpg

     

    - 10 Blaze Troopers

    oV47tOf.jpg

     

    Boarding:

    (Boarding parties do not take units away from garrison crew members)

    - 10 LAAT Gunships (Containing 1 Blaze, 1 Commando, 1 Shadow and 1 ARC Trooper each)

    - 30 LAAT Gunships (Containing 4 Clone Marines, 1 Heavy Gunner, 1 Heavy Trooper, 1 Clone Sniper and 2 Jet Troopers each)

    - 2 (Containing 1 Commander, 2 Captains and 7 Clone Marines each)

    ZGPK5PV.jpg

     

     

     

    So who wins?

  4. To be fair, most people only play call of duty for the multiplayer, and advanced warfare had a good campaign, people just rip on it because it's call of duty.

    Infinity ward have been downright lazy they haven't made a decent CoD since MW1.

    MW2 was pretty good tbh, I liked the spec ops missions but zombies are better in my opinion

  5. So I tried to synchronize some music with game trailers, Imma show them off here! Tell me what you think! ʕ•ᴥ•ʔ

     

    Star Wars: The Old Republic

    STEPS

    I. Play and pause the music at 0:00 to ensure it starts quickly when you play it later

    II. Pause and mute the trailer at 0:35

    III. Play both videos at the same time and enjoy!

     

     

     

    PlanetSide 2

    STEPS

    I. Play and pause the music at 0:00 to ensure it starts quickly when you play it later

    II. Pause and mute the trailer at 0:12

    III. Play both videos at the same time and enjoy!

     

     

     

     

    DC Universe Online

    STEPS

    I. Play and pause music at 0:02

    II. Zoom trailer into full screen and on bottom right settings change speed to 1.5

    III. Pause and mute the trailer at 0:40

    IV. Play both videos at the same time and enjoy!

     

     

     

     

    Sorry DE, couldn't figure anything out for warframe... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

×
×
  • Create New...