I need some help... :(

[xX_JohnWick2007_Xx]

DAMN IT WHICH ONE

[jjadned]

First one.

Edited December 14, 2016 by jjadned

[xFrostKnightx]

Easily the first one. Even with -40% damage it still has elemental bonus, which is worth more than a tiny increase of damage.  
Weapon damage:  1,000
With 1st card. 3,000,  with second card. 2,400.  
These are not super accurate but it's a rough estimate for the example. 

[ashrah]

first one is way better... i dont like use any mod who give negative dmg and that little negative u can counter with  wild fire.. so win win

Edited December 14, 2016 by ashrah

[Heckzu]

5 minutes ago, ashrah said:

first one is way better... i dont like use any mod who give negative dmg and that little negative u can counter with  wild fire.. so win win

The simulor has 0 IPS, so the -puncture and +slash effects have no effect on the weapon

[ashrah]

1 minute ago, Heckzu said:

The simulor has 0 IPS, so the -puncture and +slash effects have no effect on the weapon

i know but if get second one then is better heavy calibar insted... first one give him overal lot dmg

[Gelkor]

I'd say the second one, TBH. 

Higher base damage contributes a ton to damage scaling from all other mods, bonus magazine capacity will be helpful IMO. 

Edited December 14, 2016 by Gelkor

[Gelkor]

46 minutes ago, ashrah said:

i know but if get second one then is better heavy calibar insted... first one give him overal lot dmg

+51% bonus elemental damage is way weaker than  +35% base damage. That +35% base damage is applied to every single element mod he would put on it. Which would eclipse +50% electrical damage with just two element mods. 

Edited December 14, 2016 by Gelkor