There is no sense of fulfilment from randomized debuffs & requirements that completely suck the fun out of using your favorite tools & mains. I think you went overboard with the debuffs in a sense that they are utterly unfun. Not to mention the rewards are absolutely NOT worth it. Truthfully I can't think of any reward that justifies going through this suffering. I haven't touched the Circuit after getting one incarnon exactly due to the reasons regarding RNG.
I get that you want to keep 50+ frames and weapons relevant but that's not the way. I dread to see this approach becoming the future endgame...